Written by Sarah Campise Hallier
Edited by Nicki Steinberger, Ph.D.
EDITOR’S SUMMARY: From sports drinks to fruit-based sodas, today’s grocery coolers are flooded with bottles promising health. Yet most are loaded with sugar, additives, or vague “natural” claims, leaving you hard-pressed to find anything genuinely nutritious. This overview unpacks how it all developed, why labels mislead, and what you can reach for instead.
Walk into a supermarket looking for something refreshing, and you’re met with an overwhelming sea of beverages. Endless shelves of shiny bottles promise vitality and energy. Sparkling waters tout “natural flavors,” juices boast “cold-pressed purity,” and sports and energy drinks line the wall. Yet despite all these choices, something is missing. If you’re looking for a drink that’s both convenient and nourishing, you may leave with nothing more than a bottle of water.
The desire for quick, portable wellness has been around for decades. Protein bars, packaged snacks, and wellness powders have now migrated into bottles. From vitamin waters to flavored lattes, you’re drinking what you once ate, hoping it helps you feel better quickly. Social media influencers, marketing campaigns, and wellness trends feed that urgency, encouraging you to reach for bottles that promise to boost, cleanse, or balance. But the farther you move from water, the harder it becomes to find beverages that are healthful and clean. To understand why the grocery aisles are flooded with options that rarely deliver, you have to step back and ask two questions. How did beverages beyond water become a central part of modern life, and why does genuine nutrition seem to vanish once it’s poured into a bottle?
The path that led here
For most of human history, water was the main source of hydration. You might have supplemented it with unpasteurized milk from the family cow or goat, or with herbal infusions and early forms of fermented drinks like mead, kvass, or lightly soured tea. Alcohol had its place at special meals and celebrations. But the choices stopped there. When you were thirsty, you drank water. When you needed comfort or wanted to warm up on a chilly day, you brewed tea.
The transition began in the twentieth century, and it started with soda. Coca Cola and Pepsi did not just sell a new drink. They sold you a lifestyle, through slick marketing campaigns. Soda became a symbol of refreshment, fun, and modern life. It gave consumers more than hydration. It offered an iconic, American identity that quickly spread across the globe. That message worked so well that soda consumption rose from 11 gallons per person per year in 1947 to over 49 gallons in 2001, with nearly 2 billion daily Coca-Cola drinkers worldwide today. From there, the options multiplied.
Sports drinks entered the market in the 1960s, pushed on athletes and then picked up by everyone. Juice boxes became the default for kids’ school lunches. Energy drinks arrived in the 1990s, offering caffeine wrapped in the image of strength and performance. Kombucha and protein shakes followed in the new century, and by then the idea that health could be bottled, branded, and sold was already familiar.
The drive for convenience pushes this even further. Instead of orange slices at an afterschool baseball game, kids often end up with plastic bottles of orange-flavored drinks. Fruit smoothies replace meals, pulled from bags and swallowed on the go. The less whole food makes it onto the table, the more demand grows for functional drinks that promise to keep you fed, healthy, and further distanced from the ritual of a family dinner. And instead of fixing the broken food system, companies step in to sell bottles claiming to deliver the very nutrition missing from your plate.
Beyond personal preference, tradition plays a quiet role in influencing drinking habits. In countries like Italy, France, and Spain, people still drink mostly water, wine, and coffee. Meals are built around seasonal foods and community, and other than water and wine, beverages aren’t offered at every meal. In America, by contrast, marketing campaigns push beverages to the forefront of the dining experience. Soft drinks are the norm at the table, and sweet tea—along with lemonade—remain staples in restaurants across the U.S. Starting in the ’80s, a generation grew up expecting a flavored drink with every bite, making plain water feel boring or unsatisfying. By the time the wellness industry began selling kombucha and cold brew, the habit of reaching for a bottle was already woven into daily life.
The blurred lines of natural
In the United States, there is no official legal definition for the word natural when it comes to beverages. The Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has instead followed a “longstanding policy” on the use of the term. According to the FDA, natural generally means that a product does not contain artificial or synthetic additives, such as colorings or flavors that would not normally be expected in that food. This policy does not consider how the product was produced, including the use of pesticides, genetic engineering, or industrial processing, and it doesn’t address health or nutritional benefits. The FDA’s position was most clearly laid out in the Federal Register, which means that when you see natural on a label, it doesn’t guarantee much beyond the absence of synthetic additives—even though the product can still contain heavily processed components. In practice, “natural” is just branding gloss rather than a meaningful health claim.
Because of this, companies often use the term in ways that can be confusing, and while the Federal Trade Commission could step in if a claim is found misleading, there is no clear rule. That walk through the grocery store quickly takes on new meaning when you notice the disconnect between marketing and ingredients. What looks like wellness is often just a story written on the label, not the drink itself.
The challenge of bottling nutrition
For the most part, nutrition doesn’t hold up in a bottle. Vitamins, antioxidants, and enzymes are delicate—they break down the moment foods are harvested, cut, or cooked. That’s why a fresh apple browns minutes after slicing, while an apple-flavored drink can sit in the cupboard for months. What’s keeping it “fresh”? Not the nutrients. Because whole foods can’t be neatly packaged into shelf-stable drinks, what fills the gap is often sugar, additives, and marketing. Labels like “low sugar” or “immune boosting” create a sense of health, even when the drink itself offers little more than sweetened water. Research shows how powerful those claims are. From “The health halo effect of ‘low sugar’ and related claims on alcoholic drinks: an online experiment with young women”:
“Participants who viewed drinks with low sugar claims rated them as healthier, less harmful to health, lower in sugar and [calories], and more suitable for weight management and a healthy diet than participants who viewed identical drinks with no claim.”
The drinks were the same—the only difference was the label. Another study, “If it tastes good, I’m drinking it”: qualitative study of beverage consumption among college students,” found that “juice has a ‘health halo’ even when students recognized it had high sugar content.” Despite that awareness, the label still shaped their sense of which bottle seemed healthiest. The truth is simple: you can’t bottle the crunch of nuts, the fiber of fruit, or the nourishment of a salad. What ends up in the drink section is more image than sustenance—packaging that disguises the absence of real nutrition. Still, the options keep multiplying—a cascade of bottles competing for your attention.
Drinks by the Dozen
Water
At first glance the water section seems straightforward, until you notice how many containers try to convince you that water needs improving. H₂O is now “smart,” “essential,” or “enhanced.” You see flavored waters with “natural fruit essences” created in labs, like ethyl butyrate, a compound used to mimic citrus flavor, or vanillin, the synthetic version of the molecule that gives vanilla its scent, along with other chemical flavor extracts designed to mimic fruit. Electrolyte waters may contain added potassium chloride, sodium bicarbonate, or magnesium sulfate—minerals that sound impressive but are unnecessary for the average person and, in some cases, potentially harmful. “For most people, it is absolutely true that we get adequate amounts [of electrolytes] in the foods and beverages that we consume already,” stated Dr. Sara Rosenkranz, associate professor of kinesiology and nutrition sciences at the University of Nevada, Las Vegas.
While they are necessary for high-intensity exercise or when you’re losing significant fluids, most daily needs can be met through a reasonably varied diet. The challenge is that the highly processed Standard American Diet often falls short of that balance—one reason these products appeal to so many. Still, the healthiest option is usually the plainest one—yet it often hides among rows of flashier choices.
Beyond the ingredients, the packaging adds another layer of concern. Recent studies have found bottled water can carry thousands of microscopic plastic particles per liter—tiny fragments that leach from packaging. These microplastics are small enough to enter the bloodstream, raising new questions about long-term health effects—turning what’s sold as a clean choice into a hidden concern. As A Voice for Choice Advocacy noted in “Human Consumption of Microplastics: 2023 and Beyond”:
“Exposure to microplastics may increase your risk for obesity by affecting metabolism, and promoting the growth of fat cells. Lab mice exposed to microplastics in their bodies had worse memory and learning skills. And ingested microplastics can also deform cell membranes and disturb their functioning.”
Juices
Across the juice display, labels are covered with images of orchards and words like “pure” or “100 percent.” Yet, according to the Cleveland Clinic, what you’re really buying is liquid sugar—sometimes as much as 25 grams in a single serving. Even cold-pressed juices that promise extra nutrients often rely on apple or grape juice concentrate as a base, with citric acid for tartness and ascorbic acid (vitamin C) to extend shelf life. Concentrate is made by removing the water from juice during processing, leaving behind a thick, sugary syrup that can be stored and later reconstituted with water. Manufacturers use it because it is cheaper and sweeter. Drinking juice may feel like a healthy choice, but your body processes it much like soda—sweetness without the fiber of whole fruit. And when you look closer, juices marketed to kids normalize high sugar intake early, teaching both children and caregivers to equate sweetness with health.
Fruit-sweetened sodas
Soda hasn’t disappeared—it’s been reinvented. Many brands now market “natural” sodas made with fruit juice, agave nectar, or cane sugar as cleaner alternatives. Labels highlight “made with real fruit” or “crafted with botanicals,” but nutritionally, most cans still deliver 20–30 grams of sugar. Agave may sound wholesome, yet it contains more fructose than table sugar, which can burden the liver when consumed regularly. Despite their updated branding, these drinks carry the same metabolic drawbacks as traditional soda: blood sugar spikes, empty calories, and a steady pull toward sweetness. And research confirms it: a JAMA Network Open study found that fruit juices—though naturally derived—often contain as much sugar and calories as sugar-sweetened beverages, and the body’s metabolic response is nearly identical.
Sports and energy drinks
Sports drinks may claim to hydrate and replenish, but most of the time you are drinking them in an office or a classroom, not on a field. The electrolytes they provide—sodium citrate, potassium chloride, and magnesium carbonate—are overshadowed by added sugars, dyes, and preservatives. Those extras come with documented health costs. Excess sugar contributes to metabolic syndrome, weight gain, and dental issues, while artificial dyes like Red 40 or Blue 1 have been linked to hyperactivity in children.
California has already banned Red 3 statewide through the Food Safety Act (AB 418), set to take effect in 2027, and passed the School Food Safety Act (AB 2316), which bans Red 40 and other synthetic dyes in public school meals beginning December 31, 2027. Preservatives such as sodium benzoate can irritate sensitive systems and add to the chemical load your body must process, especially when combined with other additives. In some cases, it has been linked to inflammation and may trigger allergic reactions or worsen asthma symptoms in vulnerable individuals.
A typical sports drink ingredient list might include high-fructose corn syrup, sucrose acetoisobutyrate (a stabilizer), citric acid, malic acid, vitamin additives, and those synthetic dyes—Blue 1 or Red 40. Energy drinks go a step further, layering in caffeine, guarana, and taurine—an amino acid that isn’t harmful on its own but is often added in excessive amounts—along with artificial sweeteners such as sucralose or acesulfame potassium. Combined with high caffeine, this mix can stress the cardiovascular system and raise health concerns with regular use. Instead of giving you clean fuel, these beverages can trigger blood sugar crashes, erode tooth enamel, raise blood pressure, and in some cases, disrupt heart rhythm.
Plant-based milks
At first glance, these dairy alternatives look like simple substitutes. You may reach for almond, oat, soy, or coconut milk thinking you are making a clean choice, but many cartons contain additives—and in the case of soy, often come from genetically modified crops unless labeled organic or non-GMO. And sometimes you are: it’s possible to find options made only from water and the plant itself, without additives. A few brands even sell pure coconut milk with no stabilizers or emulsifiers at all. Most cartons on store shelves, though, contain surprisingly little of the actual plant. From “A Review of Plant-Based Drinks Addressing Nutrients, Flavor, and Processing Technologies,”researchers note:
“The content of the plant material in plant-based drinks is generally low, ranging from 2 to 20%, and therefore the nutritional quality depends largely on the raw material and the fortification applied.”
The rest is water bulked up with added oils—like sunflower or canola, which are high in omega-6 polyunsaturated fatty acids (PUFAs)—stabilizers such as gellan gum or guar gum, emulsifiers like lecithin, and sugar for taste. While these ingredients help with shelf life and texture, they also come with downsides. Excessive omega-6 oils contribute to inflammation and oxidative stress, gums may disrupt digestion, and added sugars spike insulin and undermine metabolic stability. What starts as a healthy-sounding alternative often ends up a highly processed beverage. In the end, it may deliver added vitamins and minerals, but it lacks the nourishment of whole foods—leaving you with a long ingredient list your body doesn’t actually need.
Kombucha and probiotics
Kombucha has become a wellness star, offering probiotics and the image of gut health in a fizzy bottle. While fermentation does create beneficial acids and bacteria, many commercial kombuchas are loaded with cane sugar or fruit juice concentrates to mask their natural sourness. And while some of the sugar is consumed during fermentation as the yeast and bacteria feed on it, not all of it disappears. In fact, the amount that remains depends on how long the brew ferments and how the brand formulates the product.
Many bottled kombuchas still contain 10–20 grams of sugar per serving—and with two servings per bottle, that can climb quickly. This means your body processes it much like any other sweetened beverage: a quick rise in blood sugar followed by an insulin crash. The illusion of balance hides the reality that sweeteners can outweigh any probiotic benefit. And because fermentation leaves trace amounts of alcohol, some bottles reach levels that raise concerns for kids or for anyone avoiding alcohol altogether.
Protein shakes
Ready-to-drink protein shakes crowd the cooler, sold as convenient all-in-one nutrition. Advertised as fuel for muscles, energy, and recovery, they promise more than they deliver. A glance at the ingredient label shows why. Isolates from whey or peas are highly processed extractions stripped of fiber and nutrients, and not allisolates supply complete amino acid profiles the way whole food sources do. Maltodextrin, a carbohydrate that digests quickly and can hike up blood sugar, is often present—commonly derived from GMO corn unless labeled organic—as are gums like guar or xanthan for thickness, and sucralose or monk fruit extract for sweetness—all of which can disrupt gut bacteria. Add in synthetic vitamins that aren’t absorbed well, and the entire bottle is engineered to appear healthy rather than provide true nourishment. Some brands add preservatives like potassium sorbate to maintain shelf stability. These drinks feed the fantasy that a bottle can replace a banana, even outdo a salad.
It’s not that all shakes or blended drinks are bad. If you’re ordering a fresh, made-to-order organic smoothie or making one at home, you can choose clean, low-glycemic fruit like strawberries and blackberries, and include high-fat nutrition from avocados, raw almond butter, and 100% cacao. But the bottled ones? Always read the label closely so you know exactly what you’re putting in your body.
Coffee beverages
Cold brew, bottled lattes, and canned frappes now take up as much cooler space as sodas. Marketed as a smarter caffeine fix, they often deliver as much sugar as a dessert—20 to 40 grams per bottle isn’t uncommon. Creamers and flavor syrups often bring more than sweetness: vegetable oils, emulsifiers, and stabilizers are common, while “light” versions lean on sucralose or acesulfame potassium to keep sweetness without calories. And while caffeine can sharpen focus in moderation, bottled coffee drinks often contain two or three times the caffeine of a standard cup, sometimes layered with added stimulants like guarana. That combination can trigger jitters, disrupt sleep, and strain blood pressure.
On top of that, testing has found that much of the world’s coffee supply carries toxic mold residues —most notably ochratoxin A—adding another hidden health concern. What looks like productivity in a bottle often leaves you more depleted than alert. By contrast, a plain cup of organic brewed coffee avoids most of these pitfalls—no added sugars, fewer contaminants, and a caffeine level your body is better equipped to handle.
Shaping a Healthier Sip
If you want variety without the artificial extras, here are smart, simple drinks to consider:
- Tea: Brew green or black varieties, or caffeine-free herbal blends, at home for subtle flavor with minimal ingredients. Skip added dyes or stabilizers. Be mindful of caffeine levels, especially in black and green teas, which can add up over multiple servings. Look for organic varieties—tea is one of the most heavily sprayed crops. Along with caffeine, tea naturally provides polyphenols—antioxidant compounds that help protect cells—and L-theanine, an amino acid that promotes calm focus and smooths out caffeine’s stimulating effect.
- Infused water and fresh juice spritzers: Slice up cucumber, lemon, mint, or berries and let them steep in your water for fresh flavor and aroma. Infusing at home lets you control every ingredient. Skip store-bought juices. Instead, squeeze fresh fruit into sparkling or plain water, and add herbs like basil or rosemary for more complexity. Whenever possible, choose organic produce to avoid pesticide residue.
- DIY mineral mix: Stir together water, a pinch of sea salt, a squirt of citrus, and a tiny dab of real maple syrup or glyphosate-free honey for natural hydration support and daily balance. This simple drink delivers sodium, potassium, and natural sugars your body actually uses—without the neon colors or preservatives.
- Coconut water: Pour and replenish for a natural source of electrolytes—potassium, sodium, calcium, and magnesium—that support hydration, recovery, and balance. Be careful: even coconut water can be high in sugar, so check the label—some brands pack more than 10 grams per serving. Opt for unsweetened and organic versions whenever possible to avoid pesticides. Coconut water offers refreshment without additives, and its mild flavor makes it an easy choice. For the purest option, crack open a fresh young coconut and drink straight from the source.
Rethinking the beverage section
The next time you face the beverage display at your local grocer, flip the bottle around. Does it list “natural flavors” without saying what they are? Gums, oils, preservatives, or multiple sweeteners? Look for the simplest option with the fewest ingredients—the closer it is to its natural form, the better. If it’s designed to last a year on the shelf, that stability comes at a cost. And if it tastes like fruit but contains none, the flavor comes from a lab. Your body doesn’t need another marketing claim. Sometimes the best choice is just a glass of water. Your body already knows what to do with it—regulate temperature, transport nutrients, flush waste, and keep cells functioning. No added flavor or color can improve on that design, and every time you choose water, you give your body the simplest tool it’s been relying on since the beginning.
~
Published on October 16, 2025.
If you’ve found value in this article, please share it!
To support the research and health education of AVFC editorial, please consider making a donation today. Thank you.
